The Strange Doctors
Murder, mysteries, and… medicine? Yup, you read right! Hosted by two physicians who enjoy all things spooky: true crime, the paranormal, unsolved mysteries, all with a bit of morbid humor thrown in. Step into the doctor’s lounge as we dissect all the things that keep you up at night. This bi-monthly podcast is just what the doctor ordered.
Episodes
33 episodes
30. Part 2 of Laci Peterson & Colleen Stan
Part 2 is FINALLY here!!! We had an old grandma issue excuse for why part 2 is so late but clearly, we worked through it. We present you with part 2 of the Lacy Peterson case. Katie digs deep on the timeline and theories leaving the only questi...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 30
•
1:59:27
29. Christina Kettlewell & Laci Peterson
Hellooooo Strangers! We are alive, well, and back in action. Did we ever really leave? No. Did anything really change since our last episode? Also no... except that we have a treat for you this week (Let's just say long distance besties b...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 29
•
2:03:57
28. Herb Baumeister & The Lost Boys
Happy Summer, Strangers! This episode is quite dark so thankfully you all will have plenty of hours of sun to listen to this in. First case, Kate regales us with the terrible story of Herb and his victims. You will most li...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 28
•
1:41:32
27. The Murders of Bill Payne & Billie Jean Hayworth, and the Murders of Joel and Lisa Guy
Late but worth the wait (we hope). The Strange Doctors are back with two cases to dissect. In this episode, Missy tells us the bizarre and tragic case of Billie Jean and Bill Payne and how vanity can lead to sinister acts. Then, Katie horrifys ...
•
Episode 27
•
1:58:56
26. Maura Murray and Laureen Rahn
In this episode, Katie and Missy dissect two mysterious cases. First, Katie tells us the story of the eerie tragedy of Maura Murray...honestly, that one keeps me up at night. Then, Missy takes us back to the 1980s and recounts the a...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 26
•
1:57:19
25. The Victims of C.C. (Episode 25 Part 2)
This is the second half of episode 25. In this episode, Katie tells the story of how medicine can harm you when in the wrong hands. She discusses the mindless acts of a serial killer, while giving our respect and focus to the victims who though...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 25
•
58:16
25. Shanquella Robinson - (Episode 25 Part 1)
New year, same weirdos here. This week we did some DIGGING. Katie and Missy's stories had to be split into two episodes this week because they were just tooooo long. In the first episode, Missy tells us the story of a young woman who had a myst...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 25
•
1:00:00
24. Tina Bowen and The Gustafson Family & A Christmas Ghost Story
Happy December Strangers! This episode we dive right in to a story that will make your skin crawl and make you second guess every thing that goes bump in the night. Followed by a good old fashioned Christmas time ghost story! Keep it strange!
•
Season 1
•
Episode 24
•
1:03:20
23. The Story of Zebb Quinn
We are back! Missy and Katie took an unexpected break for a few weeks. Katie is in nomad land and without internet right now, so Missy was planning to fly solo for this story BUT... fear not, strangers! In this week's episode, we have our first...
•
Episode 23
•
49:17
22. LaLaurie Mansion and Dudleytown
Happy Halloween, Strangers! In this week's episode, Katie ventures down to the bayou to retell the real-life horrid acts that took place at the LaLaurie mansion. Then, Missy takes us to a small village that may or may not have been cursed by it...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 22
•
1:32:51
21. Annie Borjesson & The Moundsville Penitentiary
Spooky Strangers you are going to love this one! Missy tells us the unfortunate but confusing unsolved case of the beautiful Annie Borjesson. It's definitely a head scratcher. Then we are kicking off Spooky Season right with Kate telling us the...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 21
•
1:41:14
20. Israel Keyes & Spooky Sea Stories
Oh Captain, my Captain! This week's episode is part 2 for Katie. We dissect the evil known as Israel Keyes. Then, we dive into a few stories about the sea. Scary, spooky sea stories, that is. Thanks for listening, strangers! If you kno...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 20
•
1:35:51
19. Barbara Amaya and Jose Alfaro & Samantha Koenig
Hello beautiful humans! This episode is definitely an important one. Missy tells the stories of two victims: Barbara Amaya and Jose Alfaro and their heroic escapes from a life of misery and torture. Then Katie tells us the case of Samantha Koen...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 19
•
1:12:28
BONUS EPISODE! Ghosties & Toasties #2
Well you beautiful strangers, you didn't ask for it but we gave it to you anyways... another Ghosties & Toasties!!! Don't worry this one is just as ridiculous as the last one. We are sorry for our delay with our recent episodes so our remed...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 19
•
25:52
18. Mary Vincent & The Pollock Twins
STRANGERS! You are not going to want to miss this one! Katie tells us the harrowing tale of a real life superhero and official bad ass, Mary Vincent. Then Missy tells all about the story of the Pollock Twins and their strange passage into this ...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 18
•
1:02:47
17. The Hinterkaifeck Murders & Project Pegasus
This episode we travel with Missy all the way to Germany for a gruesome old timey murder case...and you guessed it, it's UNSOLVED! Then Katie takes us on a wild ride with Project Pegasus. Prepare to learn all about quantum access and chrononaut...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 17
•
1:21:38
16. The Bennington Triangle and the Redpath Family Deaths
Hello Strangers! This week, we got some seriously spooky cases. Katie tells a tale from the great state of Vermont: The Bennington Triangle! We are prettyyy sure we solved that one so don't miss out! Then, Missy takes us even more north to Cana...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 16
•
1:34:12
15. Clear Lake Murders & Hannah Zehner Brim
In this week's episode, we get down and dirty talking about some gruesome stories. First, Missy tells the tale of two beautiful young ladies, Tiffany Rowell and Rachael Koloroutis, who died a horrific and very personal death. Then, Katie tells ...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 15
•
1:17:26
14. Carol Lynn Sullivan & Reggie and Carol Sumner
Hello to our beautiful awesome Strangers, we are so grateful for you all! In this episode Katie takes us back in time to a small town in Florida where the young Carol Lynn Sullivan lived and died a mysterious death. Then Missy tells us the trul...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 15
•
1:10:52
13. Lauren Smith Fields & Aswangs
Hello Strangers! In this week's episode, we dissect the mysterious death of a young, beautiful, and fun-loving black woman named Lauren Smith Fields. Next, Katie fuels our nightmares with the folklore creatures of the Philippines called Aswangs...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 13
•
1:06:32
12. Michelle "Shelly" Knotek & The Hands That Resist Him Painting
Hey Strangers! In this week's episode, talk about some stuff right out of hell. First, Katie tells us about a house of horrors and the monsters who lived there. Next, Missy fuels our nightmares with one simple piece of artwork. Whatever you do,...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 12
•
1:14:43
BONUS EPISODE! Ghosties & Toasties 1
Here's the bonus episode that we promised you Strangers due to our tardiness with our last episode. This bonus piece is where Missy and Katie chat about nothing and toast to everything with a few ghost stories sprinkled in. If you don't want to...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 13
•
35:19
11. The Somerton Man and Sherri Rasmussen
Hey Strangers! In this week's episode, we got one solved and one unsolved for ya... just guess who's is who's! First, Missy dissects the case of the Somerton Man and why "Tamam Shud" is now something we all have to look up! Then, Katie takes us...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 11
•
1:31:46
10. Katherine Knight and Jessica Bergsten & the Infamous Gator Rogowski
Hey Strangers! In this week's episode, Katie dives us down under to the land of Australia to dissect a wicked case based on an even more wicked woman (apparently Satan does not even claim her...). Then, Missy takes us back to the 1980s to reliv...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 10
•
1:38:53
9. Pittsburgh Lobster Boy and the Terrifying B.E.K.
In this week's episode, Missy tells the tale of a claw-handed horrifying man with a tragic life story. If that isn't uncomfortable enough, Katie tops it off with a story that gets an A+ in the heebie jeebies. Lock your doors and keep the lights...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 9
•
1:16:12